An
aneurysm is a swelling or dilatation in a blood vessel. Aneurysms can occur in any blood vessel, but are much more common in arteries,
although they do occur rarely in veins. An abdominal aortic aneurysm
(AAA) is a
dilatation in the abdominal (tummy) part of a major artery - the aorta. This is
one of the commonest types of aneurysm.
Aortic aneurysms are fairly common
especially in older men. Hospital admission rates for
aneurysms also appear to be increasing (Filipovic
M et al, 2005). About 6% of men (6 in 100) aged 80 years will have an
aneurysm (Bengtsson H et al,
1992). They account for 1.4% of deaths in men over the
age of 65 years and 0.5% of deaths in women. Up to 10,000 people die in
the UK from a
ruptured aortic aneurysm each year (Sayers RD, 2002). They are more common in brothers and
there is an increased risk of an aortic aneurysm if you suffer from high blood pressure
or atherosclerosis
(hardening of the arteries).
Aortic aneurysms seem to be
relatively rare in Asian populations. The Maori population in New Zealand
has a higher death rate from aneurysms (8.9 per 100,000 in Maori vs 3.7 per 100,000 in
non-Maori) and require more emergency operations than the non-Maori population,
despite a slightly lower age-adjusted admission rate (12 per 100,000 vs 15 per
100,000, Rosaak JI et al,
2003).
We do not know exactly why some
people develop aortic aneurysms. They are much more common in men and may
sometimes run in the family. There seems to be an approximate four times
increased risk of having an aneurysm for the brother of a patient with an
aneurysm. Stated another way the brother of a patient with an aneurysm has
about a 10-15% chance of developing an aneurysm. Most brothers (more than
80%) will not develop an aneurysm. Surprisingly, the presence of diabetes
seems to have a slight protective effect on aneurysm development
Aneurysms may develop because of a weakness in the
tissues holding the blood vessels together or possibly an imbalance in various
enzymes (matrix metallo-proteinases or MMPs) that are found in the blood vessel
wall. No specific genes have yet been identified in relation to aneurysms
(Powell JT, 2003).
Aortic aneurysms are important
because sometimes they can burst. When an aortic aneurysm bursts it is a
catastrophic event in which the patient can die from internal bleeding in a
matter of minutes. In most people a burst (ruptured) aortic aneurysm is fatal.
The risk of an aneurysm
rupturing varies with the aneurysm size. The larger the aortic aneurysm the more
risk of it rupturing. Small aneurysms less than 5.5cms in diameter
have an annual risk of rupture of less than 1% (1 in 100). This means that
a patient, with an aortic aneurysm less than 5.5cms in diameter, has
approximately a 1 in 100 chance of it bursting over the next 12 months.
A recent Canadian study has
reported specific figures for the risk of rupture based on aneurysm size (Brown
PM et al 2003). For men the annual risk of an aneurysm rupturing was
1-1.8% for aneurysms between 5.0 and 5.9cms, but increased to 14.1-15.6% when
the aneurysm was 6cms or greater. In other words a man with a 5.4cms
diameter aneurysm has only 1 or 2 chances in a hundred that his aneurysm will
rupture in the next year. Once the aneurysm increases to 6.1cms that risk
will increase to approximately 15 chances in a hundred. In women the risks
are greater. A woman with an aneurysm between 5.0 and 5.9 cms has a
3.9 - 4.7% risk of rupture over the next year. Once the aneurysm size
increases beyond 6.0 cms the risk of rupture increases to 22 - 30%
over the next year.
Less commonly aortic aneurysms can
cause other symptoms. The aneurysm is usually lined by blood clot, which in
most people, is not dangerous. Occasionally, parts of this blood clot can be dislodged and travel downwards
to block arteries to the leg (embolism). As the aneurysm enlarges it can
cause pressure on nerves and can occasionally lead to pressure on the ureter
(the tube between the kidney and bladder). This can prevent urine draining
from the kidneys normally and the kidneys can become damaged.
Repair of an aortic aneurysm
will stop these complications developing.
At present aortic aneurysms cannot be prevented
from developing, but their growth may be
slowed by some simple measures. If you smoke, this increases the rate of
growth of aortic aneurysms and you should stop immediately. Your blood pressure should
be checked and if it is persistently raised you should have treatment to reduce
your blood pressure. High blood pressure is a risk factor for aneurysm
rupture. This does not mean your aortic aneurysm will rupture if you have high
blood pressure, but it does place it at slightly higher risk of rupture.
It is important to have your risk factors for
hardening of the arteries monitored
and treated if necessary as there is a clear increased risk of death even after
the aneurysm has been treated due to cardiovascular disease (UK
Small aneurysm Trial Participants, 2007). There is some evidence that cholesterol lowering drugs such as simvastatin, decrease the growth rate of aneurysms (Schlosser et al 2008).
Unfortunately, many people
will not know if they have an aortic aneurysm, because they rarely cause symptoms until
they burst. Aortic aneurysms are sometimes found during a routine examination for
other conditions such as prostate problems or
gallstones. If you
are a man over the age of 60 years, a smoker with high blood pressure and have a
brother or father with an aortic aneurysm, then this puts you at increased risk. If you also
have hardening of the arteries at other sites (eg previous stroke or heart
attack) then you may also be at increased risk.
Although examination by your
doctor may be helpful in diagnosing a large aortic aneurysm, it is not a sensitive
method of diagnosing smaller aneurysms. The best way to diagnose an
aneurysm is with an
ultrasound scan of the abdomen. This is a very quick,
simple, accurate and safe test that is also commonly used
to examine babies in the womb.
Occasionally, patients experience abdominal
(tummy) and back pain and the
aneurysm becomes tender before it ruptures. If this happens and you know
you have an aneurysm, then it is important to seek emergency medical advice.
Before surgery most patients
will undergo CT (computed tomography) scanning to show the aneurysm in more
detail. The picture below is a CT scan of an aneurysm. This picture
represents a slice across the abdomen. The spinal column is shown at the
back.
White arrow
points to aneurysm
T is thrombus
or blood clot inside the enlarged artery
L is the lumen
or part of the artery where blood is flowing.
IVC is
inferior vena cava or the main vein in the abdomen.
The aorta - the main blood vessel
that becomes swollen - is usually about 2.0-2.5 cms in diameter although this can vary with age and whether you
are a man or a woman.
We know from two large studies in the USA and UK (Lederle
FA et al 2002, ) that aneurysms less than 5.5 cms across can be safely watched as long as
they are monitored on a regular basis. For aneurysms less than 4.4 cms across or less,
a yearly ultrasound scan is sufficient to monitor aneurysm growth. For
aneurysms between 4.5 and 4.9 cms across, a scan every 6 months is advised. An
aneurysm greater than 5.0 cms across requires scans every 3 months.
When an aneurysm reaches 5.5
cms most surgeons would consider offering surgical intervention. This is
because, at this size, the aneurysm has a greater risk of rupture. It then
becomes as safe to have an
operation to repair the aneurysm, as it is to leave the aneurysm alone.
Surgery may also be considered if your aneurysm is rapidly expanding on regular
scans or it starts to cause other complications (see above). Rapid expansion means more than 7mm in 6 months or 1.0cms in one year. Whether you proceed with surgery will not just depend on
the size of the aneurysm. It is important that each patient is fit enough to withstand the
operation. Fitness for surgery can be affected by many factors and the
decision whether or not to proceed with surgery can be a difficult one, as it is
a very major operation. It
will only be after a detailed discussion with your surgeon, regarding your own
personal circumstances and type of treatment available, that a decision can be reached.
There is still much debate on the treatment of aneurysms between 4.0 and 5.5cms despite the large UK and North American trials indicating that there is no clear benefit. Looked at in another way though, there was no clear disadvantage to having the aneurysm treated at an earlier stage. Overall 60% of all patients in the trial would eventually require an operation so why not step in at an earlier stage? Taking patients with aneurysms over 5.0cms the argument is even more convincing, as over 80% of these patients eventually require surgery. Despite this the accepted cutoff to initiate treatment is still 5.5cms. Endovascular treatment of aneurysms (see below) has lower operative mortality than open surgery and it has been proposed that treating smaller aneurysms with stents will lead to benefits. An Italian/European trial is presently examing this specific question.
If your aneurysm bursts it
usually causes severe back and abdominal pain. The bleeding can stop
temporarily in some patients and in these patients an emergency operation can be
successful at repairing the aneurysm. The majority of patients (>70-80%) with a ruptured abdominal aneurysm will not survive.
It is important to remember
that although any anxiety you may have had about your aortic aneurysm will be relieved
by having it repaired, the operation will not make you feel physically better.
This is
because most patients do not have symptoms from their aneurysm before the operation. The
operation is a treatment to prevent the aneurysm rupturing or causing other
complications in the future.
Most aortic aneurysms are found below the arteries to the kidneys (renal arteries) in the abdomen Some aneurysms can extend upwards to involve the arteries to the kidneys, the arteries to the intestines, liver and stomach. More extensive aneurysms will involve the aorta from where it leaves the heart and can extend throughout the chest. These aneurysms are much more difficult to repair and carry much greater risks from treatment. Open surgery for these aneurysms is massive surgery, but until recently was the only treatment available. Newer endovascular treatments are revolutionising therapy in patients with these aneurysms and extending the treatment to patients who previously would have been considered unfit for open repair.
Open Surgery The traditional treatment for aneurysms is surgery to replace the diseased blood
vessel with an artificial blood vessel (graft). In the conventional open operation
a large incision is made in the abdomen. The blood vessels above and below
the aneurysm are clamped in order to control any bleeding and the aneurysm
itself is opened. Any blood clot in the aneurysm is removed and any
bleeding blood vessels are controlled. The artificial graft is then
stitched into place using permanent stitches. The graft is made from a
man-made material called Dacron, similar to Terylene.
This is a major operation
requiring 7-10 days in hospital and usually a short post-operative stay on the
intensive care unit. If you have this operation as a planned procedure
there is an overall risk of dying of around 5%. This means that 95
patients out of every 100 will be fine and come through the operation.
However, a small number of patients (approximately 5 in 100) will die in
hospital either during or more commonly after their operation. These are average results when looked at overall on a
country wide basis, although some individual units may claim better survival
figures. It is important to remember that your chances of surviving a
planned operation are much better than if your aneurysm ruptures, when the
overall chance of dying is around 80%. This means that 80 patients out of
every 100 who have a ruptured aneurysm will die.
The conventional open
operation has a history dating back over 55 years and is a very effective and
durable treatment for aneurysms. Once patients have recovered from the
operation they rarely have further problems.
Endovascular stenting Over the last 18 years a new treatment has become available (Endovascular
Aneurysm Repair or EVAR). This procedure is different from the
conventional operation because it does not usually require any cuts in the
tummy. Two small vertical cuts are made in the groin and an artificial
graft (tailored individually for
each aortic aneurysm) is deployed from inside the aneurysm itself. This operation
requires a special delivery device to deliver the graft through the
arteries to the aneurysm. At least 16 different delivery devices have been developed to facilitate this procedure and it is likely that major
advances in delivery systems will continue to simplify the operation. Click HERE to view a simulation of endovascular stent placement. EVAR is a rapidly developing field.
The stenting operation is only
suitable for patients with certain shapes (morphology) of aortic aneurysm. The number of patients suitable for EVAR varies to some extent on the expertise of the local unit. Only about
50-60% of aneurysms will be suitable for the endovascular technique, but it has
the attraction of being much less traumatic than the open procedure. As
modern generation devices are refined, more and more aneurysms are becoming suitable for the endovascular technique. Recovery is faster for most people and
it may permit much earlier discharge from hospital. More and more complex graft stents are being developed which will deal not only with abdominal aneurysms but also with complex aortic arch and thoacoabdominal aneurysm involving major branches of the aorta. When an endovascular graft is constructed with branches to supply major arterial vessels it is known as a fenestrated graft. This is expanding the population suitable for treatment as previously only relatively fit patients could withstand the major surgery involved in repair.
There are two major studies (the
Dutch Randomised Endovascular Aneurysm Management (DREAM) trial and the
Endovascular Aneurysm Repair Trial-1 (EVAR-1)) with rigorous trial
designs and protocols that have demonstrated significant improvements in 30 day mortality in
patients undergoing endovascular repair (Prinsen M et al,
2004;
Greenhalgh RM et al, 2004) when compared with traditional open repair for abdominal aortic aneurysms.
In the DREAM trial the risk of
dying from open surgery was reduced from 4.6% to 1.2% with endovascular stenting
at 30 days after operation. EVAR-1 showed a similar reduction in 30 day
operative mortality from 4.7% with open repair to 1.7% with endovascular repair.
By 1 year after surgery this benefit had disappeared in the DREAM trial patients
(Blankensteijn JD
et al, 2005). At two years the survival rates were 89.6% in the open
surgery patients and 89.7% in the endovascular repair group. The initial
advantage of having an endovascular repair only seemed to last for a short
period (months) around the time of the operation and was then lost. Similar
findings have been reported by EVAR-1 with equal survival for both groups of
patients at 4 years after aneurysm treatment (EVAR
Trial Participants, 2005). It may be that open repair precipitates
death in some of the more fragile patients who may only have a limited life
expectancy because of other serious illnesses. There is some evidence that later mortality may be greater in patients with EVAR and kidney function may also deteriorate more quickly after EVAR. Long term results from the trials will give us more information.
EVAR-2 (EVAR
Trial Participants, 2005) was a UK study which compared best medical
treatment for patients with aortic aneurysms who were not fit for open surgery.
After 4 years of follow up the overall mortality rates were high at between
62-66% and there was no benefit for these sick patients in having treatment, even
with the less traumatic endovascular technique.
Despite the benefits clearly
demonstrated on early mortality with endovascular repair, there are still two
major unresolved issues. They are the durability of the procedure and the
problem of endoleak.
Endoleak is only a problem
in patients undergoing endovascular repair. It occurs when the seal
between the graft and the normal arterial wall or between two segments of graft
is incomplete (see diagram below (Type I - V endoleaks). If the seal is not complete blood can leak through the seal
and fill the aneurysm as it did before the operation. There are also other
types of endoleak in which small arterial branches of the aneurysm continue to
fill the aneurysm sac. If endoleaks are significant and cause
pressurisation of the partly excluded sac (endotension) this can lead to aneurysm rupture - the very thing surgeons are
trying to prevent. The long term durability of endovascular stenting is
not known and it is not a risk free alternative to open surgery (Gorham
TJ et al, 2004). A recent review article in the Journal of Vascular
Surgery (Rutherford RB and Krupski WC,
2004) has concluded that in our present state of knowledge traditional open
surgical repair is still to be preferred in younger patients at low operative
risk - a view endorsed again in 2005 (Cronenwett JL,
2005). Increasingly this view is being challenged and in most current practice if a patient has an aneurysm suitable for endovascular repair then this treatment will be offered.
Durability is an issue because
endovascular repair is a recent development in which the technology has rapidly
advanced. EVAR-1 showed the risk of complications developing over 4 years
was 41% in the endovascular group versus 9% in the open repair group. Once
you have had your aneurysm stented, this may not be the end of the treatment.
Each year following the procedure, many patients require further operations to
ensure that their stent remains effective. Around 5-10% (1 in every 10 to
20 patients) will require a further procedure every year to keep the stent
working normally and prevent aneurysm rupture. With the devices currently in
use, it is essential that each patient is closely monitored after the operation,
for the rest of their lives. A recent Eurostar review reported decreased rates of
secondary intervention (further aneurysm treatments after the initial stenting
to treat the aneurysm). Four years after their endovascular graft only 14% or 1
in 7 patients required some other form of treatment to prevent the aneurysm from
rupturing and maintain circulation to the legs.
A recent
editorial has drawn attention to the 3% ongoing annual failure rate
for endovascular grafts which is 10 times more than after open surgery.
This is in addition to the annual 10% rate of further intervention in
conjunction with a need for lifelong follow-up. The author also highlights
results from the Cleveland Clinic (a well known US vascular centre) where the
results of endovascular grafting in large aneurysms were concerning with a 10%
(1 in 10) 4 year risk of rupture for aneurysms 6.5cm in diameter or greater at
the time of endovascular repair. In other words, even after apparently
successful endovascular repair patients with large aneurysms still had a 1 in 10
chance of their aneurysm rupturing.
Endovascular stenting is here to
stay and in fact is the treatment of choice for nearly half of all patients with
aneurysms in the USA (Nowygrod,
2006), but it clearly requires more research to refine the and optimise the technique and the technology.
Patients who have undergone EVAR require lifelong follow up with imaging of their graft to detect problems at an early stage. This is usually by a combination of CT scan and ultrasound with angiography reserved for treating problems when they occur.
Laparoscopic aneurysm
repair There are a few centres developing keyhole surgery for aortic aneurysm repair.
In principle this operation is the same as open surgery (see above). The
aneurysm is approached from the outside and a graft stitched into place.
It is different from the open operation because the incisions used in the
abdomen are much smaller.
It is not available as an
option in most departments and only a few expert laparoscopic surgeons around
the world are performing this procedure, although it does appear to be
increasing in popularity. It will require considerable
development if it is to become routine, but has the attraction of implanting the
graft in a traditional way but without a large incision. This would
combine the advantages of a minimally invasive and low trauma approach, with the
durability and long term freedom from complications of an open repair.
Non-surgical treatments The ultimate aim of some research is to slow or prevent aneurysm growth,
reducing or eliminating the need for surgery. There are no treatments
proven to reduce the need for aneurysm surgery but work continues. Beta
blockers, such as metoprolol or atenolol, may be helpful. A recent study (Hackam
DG et al, 2006) has reported that the use of angiotensin converting enzyme
inhibitor drugs (captopril for example) was associated with a reduced risk of
aneurysm rupture, but further studies are required.
There are a number of potential
problems that can occur after aortic aneurysm surgery. These fall into 2
main categories: generalised
complications and local complications. Both types of complication can
prolong the stay in hospital and may be
fatal if they are severe enough. There is a risk of dying from open
aneurysm surgery of between 3-7%.
Generalised complications This means problems that can occur away from the site of the
operation. They occur because a major operation under general anaesthesia
has been performed usually with significant blood loss.
The commonest
types of generalised complication usually occur in the heart or the lungs. They
take
the form of angina (chest pain), heart attacks and chest infections. In
the majority of patients, especially those having a planned operation, these
complications can be successfully treated. The combined presence of heart lung and kidney complications can result in the condition of multi-organ failure (MOF). This frequently fatal.
Local complications
This means problems related to the site of the operation.
The main early problem that
can occur is bleeding at the place where the main artery has been joined to the
artificial graft. This can be severe. The surgeon will stop all
bleeding before completing your operation but sometimes further bleeding can
develop during the recovery period - especially within the first 24 hours.
If this happens the patient can require a further operation to control the
bleeding.
Nerves controlling sexual
function run very close to the aorta. Although attempts to preserve these
nerves are usually made during an aneurysm repair they can be frequently
damaged. In men this can lead to loss of erections. If erections are
preserved, retrograde ejaculation can take place where the semen is ejected into
the bladder due to inco-ordination of the various muscles. The effects of
damage to the same nerves in women are not clear in the age group that usually
require this operation.
Sometime after the operation, infection can develop in the
artificial graft, although this is rare. If this does occur it can be a
major problem and will probably lead to further surgery to fix the problem.
Occasionally replacement of the
major artery in the abdomen can lead to impairment of the blood supply to part
of the colon (colonic ischaemic). If this becomes very severe then further surgery can be
necessary to remove the damaged colon and prevent further complications.
In approximately 20-30% of patients a weakness
can develop in the scar on the tummy. If this happens it occurs months or
even years after recovery from the original surgery. It can lead to bulging
in the abdominal wound and the
development of an incisional hernia. This seems to be more common in
aneurysm patients and may require a further
operation.
Endoleak is a complication virtually exclusive to endovascular aneurysm repair. The behaviour and management of different types of endoleak is becoming more clear cut with increased experience in this area.
To reduce the risk of DVT
Anti-embolic graduated compression stockings may be used, providing there is no evidence of hardening of the arteries in the
legs. Intermittent compression of the legs and/or feet using airbags is sometimes used in theatre to improve blood flow in the leg veins during the anaesthetic. Most
patients also receive heparin injections to reduce the risk of blood clots
forming. After your operation you will be encouraged to move around as
early as possible.
To reduce the risk of
infection
Antibiotics will be given at the start of the operation and sometimes for one or
two doses after the operation. Physiotherapy will be started shortly after
the operation to prevent secretions accumulating in the chest.
As aneurysms can be a serious health issue much effort has been directed at trying to identify aneurysms before they rupture. Screening programmes have been
used to detect patients with aortic aneurysms and to monitor the aneurysms if
they are small. An aortic aneurysm will usually develop slowly and enlarge
over a period of years. Surgery can be considered as the aneurysm
enlarges. Although these screening programmes cannot prevent aortic
aneurysms forming, they are able to reduce the chances of an aneurysm rupturing
by treating it at an early stage.
The multicentre aneurysm screening study (MASS) funded by the UK Medical Research
Council recuited 67,000 men aged 65-74 years. After 10 years of follow-up there was a 48% relative risk reduction in the risk of death from aneurysm rupture in the patients screened with an ultrasound scan (absolute risk reduction 0.41%). A recent editorial in the British Journal of Surgery has called for the widespread
introduction of aneurysm screening in the UK. The cost-effectiveness of aneurysm screening
is
comparable with other screening programmes (Thompson SG et al 2009) with a cost per life-year gained one third of the published cost per life year
gained with breast cancer screening or colorectal cancer screening and one
eighth the cost per life-year saved with cervical cancer screening. However there is debate on whether screening is cost effective (Ehlers et al 2009). In the UK the national screening body is gradually rolling out screening across England. All men will be invited for screening when they turn 65years old.
Screening studies target men
because aortic aneurysms affect men much more commonly. There is some
evidence that screening for women may also be cost effective because of their
longer life expectancy and increased risk of rupture (Wahhainen
A, 2006). Aneurysms in women, when they do occur, seem to enlarge
slightly faster than in men (Mofidi
R et al, 2007).